04-28-2014, 10:40 AM
#1
User Info
A friend of mine gave me 2 pure badger knots
Base knot 24mm and Loft at 67mm,he get them from PC Woodcrafts and Pens.
If you remember my previous "how i test my knots" you can understand better the procedure:

Here they are out of the box:

[Image: 18116860gn.jpg]

[Image: 18116862vf.jpg]

I wash them,let them dry,i load a soap and i made palm lather
I rinse them,let the dry,here how they look like:

[Image: 18116859lz.jpg]

[Image: 18116861lg.jpg]

I took each one as is dry and made some swirling movements in my palm
No hard push just simple moves as i do in my face lather
It's not a torture,few times left to right and right to left as a normal shaving,here the results:

[Image: 18116944gl.jpg]

[Image: 18116947nm.jpg]

For me that's a knot failure,no good backbone,not adequate for a proper shaving with swirling movements,just painting that i don't like it !


In comparison with a Frank Shaving pure badger knot,24mmm knot base glued few mm inside the handle.
Here they are before the test,both of 3 of them:

[Image: 18116949ah.jpg]

Here they are after the test,take a look the FS's,almost as it was,stiff and ready for more action
The PC WP's they just collapsed !

[Image: 18116948wk.jpg]

How can i make the decision to glue those knots ?
Would any of you take the risk and glue those knots ?
Tell me your opinion.

0 353
Reply
 04-28-2014, 03:19 PM
#2
User Info
Don't waste your time, glue, or handle on those!

1 2,827
Reply
 04-29-2014, 12:28 AM
#3
User Info
My first thought was to toss them but take a look from above the diameter of those knots
Comparing to FS are smaller,if i dig the handle and put them a little deeper i thing they would look like an 20mm knots.
I am hesitate because you know my fiend how much work need to be done to remove them and clean properly the "nest" of the handle.
Should i try with silicone just for one shaving ?

0 353
Reply
 05-03-2014, 07:45 AM
#4
  • vpayne
  • Active Member
  • Missouri
User Info
Their horse hair is the same-lifeless. I would not waste my time on the two from PC WP, but would temporarily glue the FS with silicone, the make a decision.
Good luck,

33 377
Reply
 05-03-2014, 08:48 AM
#5
User Info
Thank you for your opinion
The FS is already in the handle,one of my best brushes.

[Image: 18167985li.jpg]

0 353
Reply
 05-06-2014, 07:27 AM
#6
User Info
I found a spare handle,i was not using it
A little work on the base knot,i "toss" it more in the handle to prevent overbloom
I glue it not very good but enough to do the test
and the lather began.

[Image: 18202735by.jpg]

[Image: 18202737pk.jpg]

[Image: 18202738gk.jpg]

[Image: 18202736vg.jpg]

[Image: 18202872sq.jpg]

In the beginning everything looked good but when the time for swirling came look what happened with a little pressure:

[Image: 18202869qc.jpg]

The knot under the foucet,no backbone at all.

[Image: 18202870xo.jpg]

Here it is in the end of shaving.

[Image: 18202871zs.jpg]

What you think about it now ?
Me, i am not happy at all.

[Image: no.gif]

0 353
Reply
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)