Compared to the old Proraso formula

was there more of menthol scent/cooling effect than this new formula? Because I don't get much of a whiff from this new formula at all and certainly no cooling effect that's been highly touted from many users. It does give a really good shave though.

The new formula is a better quality cream. However, it seems to be at the expense of some of the menthol smell, and cooling sensation.

(06-13-2012, 05:42 PM)somebody Wrote: The new formula is a better quality cream. However, it seems to be at the expense of some of the menthol smell, and cooling sensation.

Im not a menthol lover,but I feel the same cooling sensation than the old one.However,this is a better cream and soap.

I haven't tried the new formula yet, but I have opened a tub in the store, and to me it doesn't smell as strong as the old formula.

The scent of the green is milder (I haven't shaved with new green yet), but the new soaps and creams have better performance overall than the original ( which was already very good.)

I've tried both (just the green ones, not white or red), I think it's about the same with the new version. Didn't feel much difference.