Top 5 performing Soaps or Creams

Setting aside scent as it's mostly subjective, what are your top 5 performing soaps and creams?

For the moment I'd say:

Pens Creams
CRSW
SV
B&M
MdC

1.) Haslinger - by a long shot. It was nice to see Rudy Vey yesterday call Haslinger the best modern soap made today. I have bought & used most soaps discussed on the boards & nothing tops its performance imo. 

2.) Brutalt Bra Barbersape
3.) Mystic Waters
4.) SdM
5.) Tabac

As of today the list is:

1. Pannacrema (Nuavia Rossa)
2. B&M (LGC, Hallows)
3. MDC (Fougere) 
4. SV (Asylum Colonia, Flying Mango)
5. LPL Traditional

Everything else in my den holds the honorable sixth place

This question has been asked at least a hundred times, but since my response keeps changing, it's still fun to answer (although it might change tomorrow):

1. Czech & Speake
2. La Savonnière du Moulin
3. CWSW
4. Acqua Di Parma
5. Tabula Rasa

What!  I'm not the first to ask!

No Dave but it's all in good fun as our 'performance' tastes can change as posted by myself, Alex and Richard above!

B&M
Soap Commander
Tim's Soap
Catie's Bubbles
Saponificio Varesino

Mystic Water
Reef Point
Castle Forbes
Catie's Bubbles
TOBS

Currently - but this WILL change by tomorrow - my list is:

1. Czech & Speak
2. Klar Seifen
3. Tabula Rasa
4. Acqua di Parma
5. Xpec

Valid through 2/8  


MWF
Klar Kabinett
Mike's Hungarian Lavender
Czech & Speake Oxford & Cambridge
Route 66 A Perfect Gent

1. Pannacrema Nuavia
2. Mystic Waters
3. Stirling
4. Soap Commander
5. Reef Point

1. CRSW
2. Soap Commander
3. Musgo Real
4. Jaboman
5. O'Melhor

Penhaligons tallow English Fern soap and Blenheim Bouquet cream

Czech & Speake

Santa Maria Novella V3

ADP

MDC Fougere and traditional scents

Here is my list:

1. B&M
2. Tabac
3. Soap Smooth
4. Reef Point
5. Maggard's / Through The Fire Fine Craft (same maker)

1. Barrister & Mann Seville
2. La Savonniere du Moulin
3. Le Père Lucien
4. RazoRock P.160 Special 
5. Martin de Candre Lavender

--
John

At the moment:

Cold River Soap Works
Mystic Waters
Barrister & Mann 
Obsessive Soap Perfectionist
Soap Commander

• Pannacrema Nuavia
• Mystic Water 
• Saponificio Varesino
• IColoniali Mango
• Eufros/Jabonman
  

That's a tough question because I have many great performing soaps and creams. I am not buying average performers, thanks to the good reviews here in TSN.

Let me think about it...

• Pannacrema
• Barrister & Mann
• Le Pere Lucien
• Savon de Volcans
• Valobra
  

These are my Top 5s at this time. But I haven't tried the I Coloniali yet, maybe later this day or tomorrow. I have a good feeling about this soap!

One thing I thought about recently was I have moved away from Vegan soaps during the winter months and that my favorite soaps will change during the warmer months.

Been using CRSW and B&M as they give me a bit more protection in the post shave but as the weather becomes more gentle, less wind, more dry, and hotter, I will pull out the Le Pére Lucien and Saponificio Varesino soaps more.

(02-08-2016, 10:31 AM)zaclikestoshave Wrote: One thing I thought about recently was I have moved away from Vegan soaps during the winter months and that my favorite soaps will change during the warmer months.

Been using CRSW and B&M as they give me a bit more protection in the post shave but as the weather becomes more gentle, less wind, more dry, and hotter, I will pull out the Le Pére Lucien and Saponificio Varesino soaps more.

Tend to this as well - more Tallow in the winter, more veggie in the summer!