ADP tube v. tub

Anyone compare tub v. tube of the most recent version. I've just swappd for a tube and am curious...

(02-14-2016, 10:01 AM)daverasi Wrote: Anyone compare tub v. tube of the most recent version. I've just swappd for a tube and am curious...

Tube is good but Tub is better, Dave.

Wait for Matt to chime in (Nero).  He has a lot of experience with these ADP products.

(02-14-2016, 11:30 AM)Steelman Wrote:

(02-14-2016, 10:01 AM)daverasi Wrote: Anyone compare tub v. tube of the most recent version. I've just swappd for a tube and am curious...

Tube is good but Tub is better, Dave.

Wait for Matt to chime in (Nero).  He has a lot of experience with these ADP products.

How do they differ, Ron?

(02-14-2016, 11:30 AM)Steelman Wrote:

(02-14-2016, 10:01 AM)daverasi Wrote: Anyone compare tub v. tube of the most recent version. I've just swappd for a tube and am curious...

Tube is good but Tub is better, Dave.

Wait for Matt to chime in (Nero).  He has a lot of experience with these ADP products.

Haha, thanks Ron!
Everyone has their personal preferences (I have seen at least one review of someone who prefers the tube), but I did find the jar better. I haven't used the tube in a long time now, but I remember I felt there was more cushion from the jar. Bit more concentrated too.
FWIW, I use the jar like a cream (scoop with finger), I do not load it like a puck of soap.
(They do have different ingredients lists.)

Great, Matt and Ron...now I need to trade for a tub so I can compare.

Tube lathers more easily, pot is just better - more cushion, more slickess, just a better product overall.

Tube is great for travelling, you can lather it with your fingers, in case you travel without a brush.

I have my tube at a hotel I stay in every second week.

(02-14-2016, 03:53 PM)daverasi Wrote: Great, Matt and Ron...now I need to trade for a tub so I can compare.

Dave...no need to get rid of your tube. Like Claus mentioned...it's great for travel and it is STILL a GREAT product....just not quite as good as the jar.  You don't need to get rid of the tube, just add the jar!

I prefer the latherability of the (tubed) soft cream - easier to load and lather. However, (lately, in my colder/drier weather) the tube has been (noticeably) drying out my (otherwise normal) skin.

(02-14-2016, 06:43 PM)ask4Edge Wrote: I prefer the latherability of the (tubed) soft cream - easier to load and lather. However, (lately, in my colder/drier weather) the tube has been (noticeably) drying out my (otherwise normal) skin.

Really ?

I find my pot of the new ADP extrmely easy to load and lather, the tube is just even easier, so easy, that I think it's made for use without a brush also (travelling)

(02-14-2016, 07:44 PM)CHSeifert Wrote:

(02-14-2016, 06:43 PM)ask4Edge Wrote: I prefer the latherability of the (tubed) soft cream - easier to load and lather. However, (lately, in my colder/drier weather) the tube has been (noticeably) drying out my (otherwise normal) skin.

Really ?

I find my pot of the new ADP extrmely easy to load and lather, the tube is just even easier, so easy, that I think it's made for use without a brush also (travelling)

Yes, although I've never had any serious difficulty lathering the jar product either; it's just that a dollop of the tubed product (versus a removed dollop of the jar product) loads/lathers a bit easier, I find. 
The drying effect (of the tube) on my (rather normal) skin, has been a bit dissapointing; I'm sure my cold/dry weather has much to do with this, but most of my other (preferred) lathering agents don't produce this effect. I haven't noticed any particular drying effect from the jar version, either.

(02-14-2016, 05:28 PM)Steelman Wrote:

(02-14-2016, 03:53 PM)daverasi Wrote: Great, Matt and Ron...now I need to trade for a tub so I can compare.

Dave...no need to get rid of your tube. Like Claus mentioned...it's great for travel and it is STILL a GREAT product....just not quite as good as the jar.  You don't need to get rid of the tube, just add the jar!

I'd love to add...via trade