Alcohol Free Aftershave Like Pinaud Clubman?

Can anyone recommend an alcohol free aftershave that has a scent very similar to the classic Pinaud Clubman?

PAA makes "Clubguy" (a tribute to Clubman) alcohol-free tonic/AS.

(02-19-2016, 11:07 AM)Maranello Wrote: PAA makes "Clubguy" (a tribute to Clubman) alcohol-free tonic/AS.

Thank you! I'll check it out.

Just placed an order for a tube of this balm.  Will update after it arrives.

http://phoenixartisanaccoutrements.com/p...-more-4-oz

A friend of mine that I got to expand his horizons in wet shaving was in love with Pinaud Clubman and had all the talcum powders etc etc . I gave him a tub of Clubguy and now that's all he orders soap wise and aftershave. He said it's the closest thing he has smelled to it.

(02-19-2016, 11:07 AM)Maranello Wrote: PAA makes "Clubguy" (a tribute to Clubman) alcohol-free tonic/AS.

NICE! On it, thanks!

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk

PAA's aftershaves are great!

Welcome!...and, btw I'm not the biggest Clubman fan by far but all of your enthusiasm makes me want to buy some again lol

I ended up ordering some of the Clubguy shaving soap to go with the balm.  Great products that perform very well and provide the scent I was after without any alcohol burn.

I like the burn & I add witch hazel with 15% alcohol to my no alcohol after shaves. To each his own, My local barbar makes his own shave products & adds no alcohol to any of his great line, Wicked Rascal brand.

Dave

I love the smell of clubman but not the alcohol.  I took some alcohol free witch hazel aND added 3 parts WH to one part clubman.   Gives me the scent without the high alcohol and it's pretty cheap to boot.