Favorite Mentholated soaps and AS splashes

Hello my name is matt and I  am a menthol addict. Im pretty new to wet shaving and have just discovered that I  love mentholated soaps and aftershaves. However being so new I  haven't had the opportunity to try many out, I picked up maggard orange menthol soap and as and have stirling spice splash and just ordered margaritas in the Arctic. We just had a baby so my spending is on hiatus for awhile however when I do have a couple spair dollars I would like some suggestions on some good mentholated soaps and splashes. So if you don't mind tell me what you like and why. Thanks!

Chiseled Face has many mentholated splashes. I like the Sherlock scent best and it gets my face as cold or colder than my other menthol splash, Aqua Velva.

The absolute coldest soap I've used is the Sterling Glacial Soaps and witch hazels. I have the Glacial Obsidian soap and the Black Ice Witch Hazel. They are VERY COLD.

Not the coldest, the I find myself reaching for good old Proraso most often. With the preshave applied first, it is pleasantly mentholated. And for splashes, why not grab a bottle of m-bomb from The Shave Den Shop and then you can add as much menthol to any splash (or your soap lather) as you like?

- I Coloniali Mango Oil (soap, mild cooling)
- I Coloniali Rhubarb (cream, mild cooling)
- TOBS Peppermint (cream, intense cooling)
- Proraso Green (soap, and cream, intense cooling)

My personal fave mentholated splash is D.R.Harris Arlington, but it's somewhat pricey; LEA Classic is less expensive, and functions very well too, imo.
I don't care for the fragrance used in the current Proraso Green splash, but it functions well, and has plenty of menthol. YMMV.

I Coloniali Mango
RR SMDF
First Canadian Shave Soap Polar Vortex

Sent from my HTC One_M8 using Tapatalk

Palmolive Menthol Shave Cream is very cold for a cream -- much colder than Proraso in my opinion.  Myrsol Plastic is a pretty cooling aftershave in my experience as well.  For some reason I get more of a cooling from it than other Myrsol products.  And of course 444 Balm/ gel is very cooling too.

Ingram and Godrej Menthol Mist are both excellent.

--
John

Fine Snake Bite & Chiseled Face Cryogen..........feel the burn : )

SdV shave stick with Mint and donkey milk. Excellent stuff!!!!

QC Vostok & Iced Key Lime soaps
Jabonman Lima & Especies soap

(03-01-2016, 03:31 PM)Nero Wrote: SdV shave stick with Mint and donkey milk. Excellent stuff!!!!

Yes!!!

Another vote for Stirling Glacials


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Catie's Bubbles Mile High Menthol shave soap and aftershave.

Stirling Orange Chill. But I love menthol so I just add mentholated glycerin drops to any soap/cream that I use.

B&M Arctique! Coldest shave yet!

Mystic Waters Prospect Creek is a nice one!

Mystic Waters Prospect Creek is very good.

OSP Grapefruit Menthol is brilliant. 

Fine L'Orange Noir Splash is my favourite.

Razorock SMdel Fiore soap
Santa Maria Novella old version  soap 
Alt Insbruk A/S lotion

I use Proraso splash and Osage rub almost daily.