Abbate Y La Mantia

I ran out of Krokos last weekend. Ordered another jar from Barbiere di Figaro in The Netherlands. And...holy cow, it arrived yesterday. Less than a week!

Italian Barber is out of stock, and I really wanted some more, so I figured I'd give them a try. And, well, you know, since the shipping charge is the same for one or four jars, I decided to try a few of their other kinds.

Now, you might recall that I am moving toward unscented shaving soap and cream. Since the scent is really light, I consider Krokos to be in that category. As for the others...ummmm, well, there's no rush. I'm still sort-of moving in the direction of unscented. OK, I will be moving in that direction. They just looked really interesting, and I want to give them a try. They sure smell fine in the tins. Will try them this week.

Abbate Y La Mantia's website says they have a new product coming out—a coconut and banana soap. I'm tempted. Perhaps I can wait until the end of the summer to go unscented.

Maggard just added in there inventory

Laureato is an amazing scent!

So, I shaved with Crumiro this morning.  Superb performance, great moisturizing, and no sensitivity issues.  However, the scent is very light.  Extremely light.  It's lovely, but almost not there.

Laureato seems to be much stronger, and smells wonderful in the tin.  I'll give it a try.

And, I hit send with Maggard and am looking forward to the arrival of Matteo and Vulcano.  The descriptions have sure got my interest!

I've wanted to try the Krokos, as I've heard great things. I also prefer unscented or at least very lighly great smelling soaps. How would you compare it to the best of the best like Nuavia, SMN, I Coloniali or Valobra?

Excellent question.

I can only compare it to SMN and Valobra Fougere.

All terrific soaps. But it's a bit like comparing Ardbeg to Langavulin and Bowmore. There'll all spectacular, and I love all of them, and have 'em all in rotation.

I used SMN this morning. Performance-wise, about the same as Krokos (excellent). After shave feel (moisturizing), I think Krokos is better. Scent? Very different. Both light. Both wonderful. I think SMN might appeal to more guys than Krokos, which is quite "different." I've grown to love it. SMN is more refreshing. Krokos is warm, comforting, and...special. Maybe even a little medicinal. It is great on my sensitive skin. Maybe the saffron, who knows?

Valobra tomorrow.

I tried Valobra yesterday.  Ahhhh, haven't had that out of the drawer in a very long time.  Don't know why it wasn't in rotation.

Difficult comparison.  Like Hendrick's or Bruichladdich with tonic on a hot day.  Both are sublime.

Performance-wise, well, as before, about the same as Krokos (excellent).  After shave feel (moisturizing), oh my, hard call.  Very hard call.  Valobra might, and I emphasis "might," be a tiny bit better.  Scent...well, I've never been a big fan of the scent of Valobra.  Don't dislike it at all, but I don't find it particularly interesting.  So, Krokos wins in that department by a long-shot.

To make the comparison a little more scientific since they're so close, one of these days I'm going to do a half-and-half shave with both.  Stay tuned.

On another note, I see Don Jose is sold out already.  I guess everyone wants to try that coconut and banana scent in the summer.

(06-03-2017, 03:43 AM)David Wrote: On another note, I see Don Jose is sold out already.  I guess everyone wants to try that coconut and banana scent in the summer.

Lol, Im not a huge fan of Banana by any means but I just had to order Don Jose. Honestly more excited to receive this soap than I have any for a long time, it just sounds so unique.

Received the Don Jose yesterday. Haven't used the soap yet so I can't comment on the performance, but if you ever had one of the Banana Wacky Wafer candies that used to sell back in the 70's that is what the scent is, at least my nose. I'm not picking up very much coconut at all and definitely no scent from the saffron or menthol. Hopefully the coconut will open up a little during the shave.

(06-06-2017, 06:25 AM)Oasisdave Wrote: Received the Don Jose yesterday. Haven't used the soap yet so I can't comment on the performance, but if you ever had one of the Banana Wacky Wafer candies that used to sell back in the 70's that is what the scent is, at least my nose. I'm not picking up very much coconut at all and definitely no scent from the saffron or menthol. Hopefully the coconut will open up a little during the shave.

Where did you get it?  Maggard is sold out.

I'm looking forward to your impressions.  I hope the coconut is noticeable.  (I can't help but think of Simpson's Vanilla & Rose—I can't detect any Vanilla).

The only Abbate Y La Mantia product that seems to have the saffron scent is Krokos.  I can't detect it in the others that I have.

(06-06-2017, 08:59 AM)David Wrote:

(06-06-2017, 06:25 AM)Oasisdave Wrote: Received the Don Jose yesterday. Haven't used the soap yet so I can't comment on the performance, but if you ever had one of the Banana Wacky Wafer candies that used to sell back in the 70's that is what the scent is, at least my nose. I'm not picking up very much coconut at all and definitely no scent from the saffron or menthol. Hopefully the coconut will open up a little during the shave.

Where did you get it?  Maggard is sold out.

I'm looking forward to your impressions.  I hope the coconut is noticeable.  (I can't help but think of Simpson's Vanilla & Rose—I can't detect any Vanilla).

The only Abbate Y La Mantia product that seems to have the saffron scent is Krokos.  I can't detect it in the others that I have.

Yeah I purchased from Maggards when they had about 10 left. Will probably use it this coming weekend

Almost a complete set.  All I need now is Don Jose.  I'm really into this brand at the moment!  Quite addictive.