Played it 'till you hated it scents

Here's mine..

Proraso sandalwood

Palmolive classic

Old Spice original cream

I never use PAA Oud Spice anymore. I guess when I started I liked the scent, but lately I prefer something a little more complex. PAA Coconut Oud is a nice replacement.
I’m also pretty much done with TOBS Sandalwood, although for the longest time I used it and loved it. Similar reason.
Art of Shaving Eucalyptus I liked for a month, and then it started to smell just like medicine or some kind of antiseptic. I still use their lemon and I ordered their Sandalwood and their Coriander & Cardimom creams, but they’re under the tree for tomorrow...

I'm still waiting for an identical scent clone of AdP Colonia to come out... all the ones that have tried have not lived up to the original.

(That's not to say those others were not very nice scents, I just really want to see someone do an identical one... like USE THE DAMN FRAGRANCE and we'll pay for it, what's the confusion?)

(12-24-2017, 06:22 AM)Nero Wrote: I'm still waiting for an identical scent clone of AdP Colonia to come out... all the ones that have tried have not lived up to the original.

(That's not to say those others were not very nice scents, I just really want to see someone do an identical one... like USE THE DAMN FRAGRANCE and we'll pay for it, what's the confusion?)

I actually haven’t smelled AdP yet, but I heard Piacenza from Stirling is pretty close, no?

(12-24-2017, 07:15 AM)Ripkin Wrote:

(12-24-2017, 06:22 AM)Nero Wrote: I'm still waiting for an identical scent clone of AdP Colonia to come out... all the ones that have tried have not lived up to the original.

(That's not to say those others were not very nice scents, I just really want to see someone do an identical one... like USE THE DAMN FRAGRANCE and we'll pay for it, what's the confusion?)

I actually haven’t smelled AdP yet, but I heard Piacenza from Stirling is pretty close, no?

I'll never know.

It takes me three months to go through my entire rotation, so I do not have that problem

(12-29-2017, 05:58 PM)Tidepool Wrote: It takes me three months to go through my entire rotation, so I do not have that problem

How often do you use each product before going to the next? Just curious because it takes me about 9 months but I use each soap for a week minimum.

Clubman AS is a little bit in this category for me. As my collection has grown I'm not as drawn to it and the scent isn't as interesting.