Top 5 Soap Brands

1. Eufros
2. Declaration Grooming
3. Barrister & Mann
4. Mike's Natural Soaps
5. MdC or Saponificio Varesino (maybe the slickest in my den)

**** I love Boellis and it is probably my #1 soap but it only comes in 1 flavor, Almond*****

What say the board?

1. Cold River Soap Works
2. Eufros
3. MdC
4. Wholly Kaw
5. Mikes

1. Saponifico Varesino
2. Cyril R. Salter
3. Tcheon Fung Sing
4. Truefitt & Hill #10
5. Henri et Victoria

1. Mikes
2. Cold River Soap Works
3. Barrister and Mann
4. Saponificio Varesino
5. Nuavia

Honorable mention to i Coloniali Mango (discontinued)

Grooming Dept
Saponificio Varesino
Barrister&Mann
CRSW
Eufros

1. Valobra/ AOS-t/ C&S

2. Tcheon Fung Sing, RR, Abbate Y La Mantia, et al.

3. Crabtree & Evelyn (vintage)

4. WSP/ASW (creams moreso than soaps which are already great)

5. If my first shave with it wasn't a fluke, then PAA (and I cannot believe I'm saying that).
I used The Beach the other day and the scent and performance we're both FANTASTIC. One of the easiest shaves in recent memory. And the skin felt fantastic afterward.
I ordered a few more over the weekend, so I'm hoping it was not a fluke!!!!

1) Vintage AoS Tallow
2) Tallow Williams
3) Vintage Old Spice
4) Tabac
5) Vintage Yardley Black Label

Eufros
Declaration Grooming
B&M
Pannacrema Nuavia
CRSW (Sandalwood).

Not in any particular order.

How could I forget Adp? That's also a top rated one.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Shaved with Abbate Y La Mantia for the first time and it was Awesome (Don Jose).

1) Le savon des Volcans - for some reason this soap really works well for me
2) Wholly Kaw - King of Oud
3)Stirling - Bay Rum at the moment
4)Grooming Dept. Amber & Oud
5)BM or Declaration - probably give it to BM by virtue of scent only.
All are really close but Volcans would be my #1 the rest a close 2nd.

Granted, my experience with soaps is still limited, but here are the ones I've tried or have en route to me, in order of purchase/gifting/use:

Soaps -

1. Williams
2. Van Der Hagen Luxury
3. D.R. Harris Marlborough
4. Van Der Hagen Deluxe
5. Tabac

There was a local soap puck I bought a couple of years ago that was Bay Rum scented and had Bentonite clay in the formula, that I used after the Williams but before the Van Der Hagen.  I don't include it in the list because I don't remember the name.

Creams -

1. Taylor of Old Bond Street (Almond)
2. Taylor of Old Bond Street (Mr. Taylor's)

1. Wholly Kaw (by a considerable margin)

2. CRSW

3. Mikes Natural Soaps

4. WSP

5. Sapone Di Paolo

Barrister & Mann
Cold River Soap Works
Wholly Kaw
Stirling
Mickey Lee Soapworks

I'm a straight razor user. Slick is important to all SR users,. I also want a soap that rinses clean and doesn't clog drains, pores, or leave scum on the shaving tools.

In no particular order:

ABC , cream or hard soap
AdP
I Coloniali Mango
Valobra/AOS-t/Czech abd Speake
XPEC

Cheers, Steve

#1 Cold River Soap Works

#2 Grooming Dept

#3 Wholly Kaw

That's it... in order.

The 3 brands above have separated themselves from the pack.

Soaps:
1. MdC
2. Vintage AOS-t/C&S/Valobra
3. Mike's
4. Eufros
5. Wholly Kaw

Creams:
1. Castle Forbes
2. XPEC
3. Proraso Single Blade
4. Antica Barbieria Cola
5. Santa Maria Novella v3

Soap/Creams: CRSW Glide

I think I've come full circle......I started with classics....

MDC
AOS tallow/Czech & Speake
MWF
Cella brick
Castle Forbes

This week, my choices are:

Soaps:
Nuavia
MdC
Declaration
Tabac
Lisa’s Premium (more like a cream)

Creams:
SMN
Wm Neumann
Baume.be
Stone Cottage
XPEC

Barrister & Mann
AoS/Valobra
ASW
LPL
Mike’s

Seeing all these lists I do love Valobra/C&S, Saponificio Varesino and a new soap I just tried Abbate Y La Mantia that I absolutely loved. It is hard to do a Top 5 as these need to be in there as well! I need a Top 10. Ha Ha!