10-10-2019, 01:27 PM
#1
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
This is my second exposure to offerings from Tatara; the appropriately named Masamune Nodachi DE razor with the Nodachi SB and original Masamune OC baseplate to serve as basis for comparison.  Relatively unknown in the US, Tatara is a small Portuguese based company founded by 3 friends with mechanical engineering education and an appreciation for Japanese swordsmith craftsmanship.  The goal was to apply their engineering acumen and love of all things samurai to improve double edge razors in craftsmanship, design, ergonomics and technology.  Focusing on minimizing blade vibration through a unique fastening system, perpendicularity of the head to handle and tight tolerances they have achieved a classic, dare I state minimalist aesthetique in keeping with traditional Japanese design and a truly unique razor.  

 
The Masamune (正宗) line is named after the greatest swordsmith in Ancient Japanese history from Sagami Province producing blades in the latter Kamakura period.  Of such renown were his swords that the most prestigious award for swordmaking, the Masamune Prize, is awarded at the Japanese Sword Making Competition to this very day (but only to a worthy candidate so not annually).  Masamunesan's swords have a reputation for superior beauty and quality, which was no small feat in that steels were far from pure during his reign.  A hallmark of his swords is the nie () finish, arising from martensitic crystals embedded in a pearlite matrix resulting from the tempering process and said to resemble stars in a night sky.  Nodachi (野太刀) refers to a long sword approximately 0,9m used by unmounted samurai in open field battles (particularly against cavalry).  The sheaved swords are often depicted as being slung across the back, as they were too long to be worn on the waist and the technique primarily employed was downward slashes - think Kendo.  These swords were exceedingly difficult to create due to the length requiring special tooling and advanced expert technique to heat and cool to the consistency required; even honing was accomplished uniquely by hanging the sword versus drawing across stones - one had to be quite accomplished and wealthy to afford such a weapon.  The reason for this brief history lesson will become apparent in the review that follows. 
 
 
                  Purity is something that cannot be attained except by piling effort upon effort 
                                                                                              Yamamoto Tsunetomo, Hagakure: The Book of the Samurai
 
 
The first thing one notices is that the packaging screams low volume craftsmanship.  While simply boxed in high-grade paperboard and - in an homage to Portuguese heritage - beautiful cork insert, the impression is one of low volume handmade craftsmanship with a nice touch of marketing sizzle.  Inside rests the most uniquely finished steel razor I have encountered; the finish has a texture and appearance imparted from the sandblasting that is so strikingly different that many of the design features are easily overlooked.  Were one to describe it, the best I can offer is it is derivative of the colour and texture of the frame/casing finish of Ducati Reparto Corse superbikes of the 90s and early 2000s.  This is the nie finish effect alluded to above and almost worth the price of admission alone.  As one stares transfixed by the finish and almost afraid to touch the razor for fear of disturbing such a unique piece of kit, other obvious design details begin to make an impression: that of being quintessentially traditionally Japanese in the sense of the simplistic elegance reminiscent of the feudal samurai weaponry that presents an aura of fragility belying its inherent strength and capability.  If the soul of the samurai is the blade, then the soul of Tatara is the blade holder.  

Once beyond the initial visual impression, differences from the original Masamune become apparent: for one, the handle is half-dimpled, half-smooth AND NOTICIBLY LONGER at 105mm.  Handling the razor brings a sense of wielding the longer nodachi versus a katana and to my hands is an improvement: irrespective, the lightness and tactile sensations are almost overwhelming being markedly different from anything else used to date whether the unique handle designs of traditional SE and DE razors, the OneBlade or even the original Masamune.  Nothing approaches how the finish, slim handle, dimpling and weight distribution of Tatara's designs synergistically interact in a positive manner to remind the user that their razors are something unique.  Having acclimated to the look and feel of the razor in hand, the next obvious design element is the retention of a flat stack height of the baseplate cap assembly which promises maneuverability and is a welcome change from the bulbous nature of recent design trends that result in making tight areas, such as around the nostrils, difficult to access.  Gone is the low stress riser/shouldered fastener cap but the Nodachi retains the recessed handle protruding through the baseplate obviously apparent as one tightens the head assembly and thankfully providing one of the most vibration free blade feels on the market.  The shouldered top cap thread was dropped to permit users opting for different handles from other manufacturers, which to my mind would be a mistake - this is a concept razor based on principles of traditional Japanese craftsmanship and design that may have quirks but loses much in translation if not experienced as a unique whole.  One element missing that should be addressed by Tatara would be to offer a nylon spacer to fill the gap between the top cap thread and baseplate eliminating lateral misalignment and movement when employing an aftermarket handle.  All 3 baseplates offered by Tatara seamlessly work the Nodachi handle and cap with the standard Nodachi SB being significantly more efficient yet skin friendly regarding the bar design than either the original Masamune OC and very much more efficient than the original Masamune SB.  The original stand design, a simple semi hemispherical beauty complementing the execution of the handle, integrates and completes the full kit should one desire to be immersed in the entirety of the design theme which, as alluded, is a signature element.  Assembled and presented, the Tatara Masamune Nodachi is even more elegant and tastefully presented than the original Masamune.  While this may be a matter of small importance, in keeping with the samurai ethos, matters of small concern should be treated seriously per Yamamoto Tsunetomo in
Hagakure: The Book of the Samurai.

 
Having experimented with various blades in quick succession, I settled on Astra SP blades which complimented the razor quite well.  As with the original Masamune, there is an overall impression of almost titanium lightness despite being constructed of 303 steel but thanks to the longer handle, the head bias that was present with the original Masamune is completely absent yet the thin almost medical instrument feel of the handle is retained.  Despite experience to the contrary, there were qualms that the slim handle and dimpled design would be quite slippy when combined with slick modern soaps such as Grooming Dept and Wholly Kaw but between the sandblasting and dimples, there was never a moment of jeopardy over the course of a couple weeks' shaves.  The finish feels unique on the face and instead of being an impediment to smooth gliding as feared, actually seems to facilitate both short and long strokes.  Indeed this is a rather unique razor!  Starting with a weeklong beard growth, the OC was used for the first pass of the first shave resulting in adequate beard reduction thanks to the unique feel afforded by the sandblasting and very defined teeth.  The second pass and every subsequent shave was undertaken using the new Nodachi baseplate solely, which was pure magic.  The combination of new smoother straight bar and more aggressive blade gap resulted in a shave similar to the interpolation of a 0,61 and 0,67 WR1 SB Wolfman - the razors used exclusively in my daily rotation along with a BBS-1 (for special occasions).  THOSE CRITICAL OF THE ORIGINAL Tatara Masamune REALLY NEED REVISIT THIS NEW MODEL.  Unlike the original Masamune, the Nodachi requires no particular technique to deliver brainless, irritation free and bbs shaves on a daily basis or even with moderate beard growth to cut through.  The wider gap also makes the razor tolerant of thicker soaps and heavy whiskers simply requiring a momentary flush under mildly running cold or warm water to clean the blade.
 
My conclusion is that this continues the beautiful and unique aesthetique Tatara has established but now combines it with one of the best shaving razors available in terms of skin friendliness, beard cutting efficiency and maneuverability.  It is limited in availability, beautifully designed, well executed and yet quite affordable.  Frankly, am adding a Nodachi to my rotation - that is the impression made by this latest offering.  I loved this this razor and would suggest 3 additional options be made available to this particular model requiring minimal additional capital:
 
1, Include a standard nylon ring filling the circumferential gap between the cap thread and baseplate for those using an aftermarket handle
The design would be all Delrin: cylandre 6,6mm OD/5mm ID extending 2,5mm height with a washer 10mm OD/5mm ID 1,0mm height

2, Offer an Open Comb and Dual Comb version of the Nodachi baseplate available using the newly designed smooth to the face blade guard

So now the razor is off to other passaround testers that will join this thread and opine; some are industry people and others highly experienced with DE razors well known/regarded on the forums.  It will be interesting to read their impressions and looking forward to the feedback which will be shared with Tatara.  There are extremely limited slots available, if you would like to be included in the passaround, PM directly.  Thank you for your time and best to all forum members.
 



[Image: j47MGrk.jpg]





[Image: IXiykAD.jpg]



[Image: rNK5dkW.jpg]



[Image: ACcEQlC.jpg]



[Image: Glz3oB6.jpg]



[Image: iMj1fsS.jpg]



[Image: PDQvF1d.jpg]



[Image: R8WAt5X.jpg]



[Image: 5uHH8a3.jpg]



[Image: GnWJCVm.jpg]



[Image: LWPc3tf.jpg]



[Image: 3mJKUbH.jpg]



[Image: 2W50c8F.jpg]



[Image: ktKnf2w.jpg]



[Image: sXNbVX0.jpg]



[Image: ZqMcIdn.jpg]



[Image: IC2n9sb.jpg]



[Image: msWKFff.jpg]


[Image: SpN83XS.jpg]


6 694
Reply
 10-10-2019, 07:08 PM
#2
User Info
Thanks for a terrific review.

60 10,408
Reply
 10-10-2019, 10:23 PM
#3
User Info
(10-10-2019, 07:08 PM)TheLegalRazor Wrote: Thanks for a terrific review.

Agreed excellent review
Thank you

32 487
Reply
 10-11-2019, 02:02 PM
#4
  • ajc347
  • Senior Member
  • Exeter, UK
User Info
Great review. Smile 

I have a Nodachi and a Masamune and really like the system Tatara have put together. They recommend using a Feather with both razors and a lot of people who have tried them find this to be a very smooth combination. I have found that a Feather works brilliantly in the Masamune but is far too harsh in the Nodachi for me. A Rapira Platinum Lux, on the other hand, improves things significantly. 

In case you are not aware, the Masamune and Nodachi top caps are slightly different and they are interchangeable with all of the handles and baseplates. Tatara have produced a chart showing the variations that can be had in terms of blade gap, with each combination. 

[Image: zyhdN0p.jpg]

If you have access to both razors, it is definitely worth experimenting with the various combinations. I like the Masmune baseplate and Nodachi combination to the extent that I have ordered a second baseplate for the Nodachi (as my Masamune is the Dark variant and a different colour baseplates and top-cap do not do it for me aesthetically).

45 767
Reply
 10-29-2019, 02:20 AM
#5
User Info
It would be nice if Tatara would also produce a shorter (76 mm) handle.  At 92 mm and 105 mm, both their handles, are too long for me.
  
There are a lot of wet shavers who, like me, prefer shorter handles.  If they make a shorter handle, they will probably sell more razors.

Just my opinion.

25 323
Reply
 10-29-2019, 11:03 AM
#6
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
The redesigned top cap works with industry standardhandles so you could try an alternative

6 694
Reply
 10-29-2019, 11:21 AM
#7
User Info
Thanks for the in depth review. Glad it was positive.  I ordered one and am awaiting it’s arrival.

0 44
Reply
 11-23-2019, 07:40 PM
#8
  • ARGH
  • Senior Member
  • Boston, MA
User Info
Thank you Dan for arranging this pass-arround, without which I would have missed on such a great experience. I was watching Tatara for quite some time, but for some reason did not feel that it would be that impressive a razor. I am glad I tried it!  My first shave was on 24hours growth. I used a fresh Gillette Nacet blade and am delighted to report that the razor DELIVERED! My top three razors are Blackbird first generation, Charcoal Goods Lvl3, and Weber DLC and this Tatara Nodachi proved fair and square that it belongs in that league. I was so impressed with the razor that I ordered my own immediately after I finished my first shave.
 
The shave went exceptionally well. Finding the shave angle was intuitive. I did three passes with a bit of a cleanup at the end. As I mentioned, it was only 24 hours since my previous shave, so there was not too much to shave.  The Sellout in the milkstake version provided plenty of cushion and glide and the three passes were smooth. I did not have much left for the cleanup and my shave ended with a virtual BBS. I was a bit overly enthusiastic and applied a bit too much pressure when doing ATG, so I ended up with a couple of irritated spots. For the second shave I will make sure to keep the pressure on the low side. All in all, it was an exemplary shave and I am very grateful for this pass-around.


[Image: 6GvVwQv.jpg]

My second shave was performed on 48-hour growth. I used the same blade, though I changed the soap to the new Siero base by Wholly Kaw. The shave went even better than the firs one. I adjusted the pressure and all three passes went absolutely marvelously with no irritation and a perfect BBS. I never tried the shorter handle that Tatara first introduced, but I am 100% happy with the Nodachi handle. Fits perfectly in my middle-sized palm and has zero problem when wet. The ATG pass felt as smooth and WTG. Will do one more shave (48hr) before sending the razor to the next fellow DFShaver on Monday. 


[Image: GmVmmuY.jpg]

125 1,891
Reply
 11-25-2019, 01:22 PM
#9
  • ARGH
  • Senior Member
  • Boston, MA
User Info
Here is my third shave set-up. Per your requests I used the Nodachi alongside the Paradigm Ti I. Same blades (Gillete Nacet). 48 hour growth. Same BBS results from both razors. Minimal touching up, no irritation on the Nodachi side; slight traces of redness on the Paradigm side.


The Paradigm has a much more pronounced blade feel and louder audio feedback. The razor is much lighter and I had to adjust pressure to make sure that I do not "dig too deep" [Image: smile.png]
The Nodachi did not require any additional care in shaving in all directions and felt smoother, especially WTG. Based on this single comparison, I can still confidently say that for me the Nodachi is as efficient as the Paradigm, but with a much lesser risk, especially if I use it as a daily driver. 

I am very glad that I tried the razor and I am delighted that my  very own Nodachi was just shipped and is due to arrive in the next couple of weeks. 

The razor is on its way to the next person on the list. 

Thank you Dan for coordinating the pass-around and thank you the Tatara Team for such an amazing razor at a very competitive price.


[Image: 2jsLqAX.jpg]

125 1,891
Reply
 12-03-2019, 10:54 AM
#10
User Info
I've used the Nodachi for 6 days straight, daily shaving including an ATG pass every single time and I have to say that I find this razor VERY smooth and efficient. It can easily be a daily driver for me. In fact, it's become one of my top 3 razors only surpassed slightly by my 1.55 WR2 and the RS-10 which is saying a lot. I find the nocachi much smoother than the Carbon and Charcoal Goods L2. For those finding this razor to be a bit much, I'd suggest trying a very shallow shaving angle. I was not expecting to be this impressed by this razor, but I sure am now. I have the nodachi with the original masamune handle and the aesthetics of the razor are also beautiful and unique. Great job on the razor guys! Definitely one of my favorite razors ever!

1 84
Reply
 12-31-2019, 11:58 AM
#11
User Info
I recently was able to participate in a second Tatara pass around, this time the Nodachi, what follows is my experience and opinion from 2 weeks usage. Again, let me start by thanking Tatara for facilitating this opportunity to experience a relatively rare razor with unique design elements. Design is an important element of all things for Italians; we view it as an integral part of our visual and tactile life experience – this commitment to unique yet elegantly simplistic design makes Tatara really stand out. Their unique treatment of the design elements of the handle texturing and blast finish are nicely done, as is the engineering of the cap threaded shank, which although no longer stress relieved at the critical juncture where razors break when dropped still provides for an absolutely solid cap-blade-baseplate interface unmatched in any other razor I have tried. They have significantly increased the handle length from the diminutive Masamune to a generous proportion but have continued the lack of finishing on the underside of the cap that signals a less than a positive impression of quality when compared to some other high-end razors. Given a choice, I probably would err on more aggressive knurling of the handle but it never slipped despite using some the slickest soaps on the market.  Funny thing is that despite the significant increase in handle length, the Nodachi felt as equally perfectly balanced as the Masamune.




As with the Masamune, my favorite characteristic of shaving with this razor is the auditory feedback; I like to hear the blade working even if some attribute this to blade vibration as it really helps me get a better shave. Another element that I thought positive was the razor's low head stack height. My current everyday razor is a custom Wolfman 0.61DC with long WRH2 handle that is the best shaver I have ever used when paired with a Timor blade; I find it shaves marvelously and is easily maneuvered around tight areas such as the nostrils and a goatee. The Tatara was equally super agile and able to quickly and effortlessly get in places that are nearly impossible to access with some other well regarded and otherwise quite good razors. Without ranting, there seems to be a trend toward ever more stack height in razor heads; congratulations to the Tatara designers for bucking the industry and sticking to their design principles! This may be the most agile modern razor I have used along with the BBS1 and Wolfman WR1.



Feather, PolSilver, and Timor blades were used with the razor.  Unlike the Masamune, which I decried as far too mild even when using super aggressive blades, the Nodachi is solidly mid aggressive and when paired with a Feather blade is simply too much for my skin and beard type.  I found the best results to come from milder blades, having my best results with Timors.  Even paired with a Timor, this razor is sufficiently aggressive that I would have to skip a day between shaves were it in my rotation.  The shaves were BBS every time, no matter what angle was attempted, no matter what blade used, the results were always the same and it was impressive indeed.



My conclusion is that the Tatara Nodachi razor would be ideal for somebody with the desire to shave every other day or seeking a mid-aggressive razor: the quality of its design amongst DE razors is superior, the production quality is outstanding if not on a level with Wolfman (but what on Earth is?), the handling is a tactile treat and the shave quality is just a tad beneath Wolfman – these are huge complements given that it costs about a quarter of the price of the Wolfman and is readily available.  Again, thank you for the chance to try this razor and I would be interested in following up with future offerings from Tatara.

0 6
Reply
 12-31-2019, 12:52 PM
#12
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
The razor is currently in GA where it will await the pairing of the newly released Tatara Nodachi OC baseplare before review and mailing to next reviewer in line

6 694
Reply
 01-15-2020, 04:44 PM
#13
User Info
My it's been quiet around here lately.

25 323
Reply
 01-15-2020, 10:34 PM
#14
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
Tatara has just provided confirmation that the newly available Noda hi OC baseplate has shipped from Portugal

6 694
Reply
 01-22-2020, 01:15 PM
#15
User Info
Hey Dan, is there a pass around with the OC plate?

1 84
Reply
 01-22-2020, 01:45 PM
#16
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
Yes it is being circulated with both bases - OC in transit from Portugal

6 694
Reply
 01-22-2020, 02:21 PM
#17
User Info
Would you mind adding me please?

Thanks Dan!!!

1 84
Reply
 01-22-2020, 02:25 PM
#18
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
pm please

6 694
Reply
 01-23-2020, 01:35 PM
#19
  • DanLaw
  • Just an old slow fat man
  • Peachtree City, GA
User Info
OC just arrived!

6 694
Reply
 01-24-2020, 05:25 AM
#20
  • DayMan
  • Senior Member
  • Tennessee
User Info
I've had the pass around razor for a little over a week now.  I am a 2 pass WTG shaver.  I can't shave XTG or ATG without getting ingrown hairs.  This is one of those razors that took a little time for me to figure out.  I used the stock Nodachi handle for the first 2 shaves and the first pass was good, but the second pass was rough.  I switched to a Weber Bulldog handle for a couple of shaves and the results were much better.  I tried switching back to the Nodachi handle, thinking that I had it figured out, but the second pass was rough again, so I concluded that the long handle just does not work for me.  I get a smooth shave with both passes when I use the Weber handle.  I have used a Blackbird, Charcoal Goods Level 2 SB, and Carbon for comparison while I've had the Nodachi in my possession.  The Nodachi has just a little less blade feel than the Blackbird.  It's not as efficient, but I would say it's about the same level of aggression.  In comparison to the Charcoal Goods, I would say that it is more efficient and more aggressive.  I would say that it is about the same efficiency as the Carbon, but it's a little more aggressive.  I have enjoyed using the razor, but not with the stock handle.  I think it's a good buy for someone who likes blade feel.  I enjoy the blade feel, but it's something I have to be in the mood for.  My recommendations to improve the razor would be to have the option for a 75 - 80 mm handle and to maybe increase the diameter of the stand.  The handle fits perfectly, but it does rub and I wonder if that will harm the finish over time.

3 726
Reply
Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)