A&E L'Orange Vert vs Fine L'Orange Noir

Is the AE scent similar to Fine's? I've smelled Fine before, but never the A&E.

Thanks in advance

I'd be curious to hear a comparison also. I love the L'Orange Noir. They look to be somewhat similar, yet different. Looks like they may have some different citrus and woody notes.

I've smelled Fine L'Orange Noir and it smells like Terre d'Hermes (which I don't like at all).  I DO like A&E L'Orange Vert though.

Fine: "Inspired by Terre d’Hermes (2006), it masterfully pairs rich earth with light orange"
A&E: "Notes: Bergamot, tangerine, lemon peel, orange, black pepper, lavender, neroli, oakmoss & patchouli."


For me, the A&E wins in more ways than just scent.